Application of Control Charts in Quality Characteristics Evaluation of Microbiological Media
Keywords:
Culture media, Quality control, Control limits, Specification limit, Statistical process controlAbstract
Microbiological culture media are the backbone of any microbiology laboratory. However, appropriate monitoring of their quality characteristics is crucial to ensure accuracy and validity of the results derived from them. The microbiologist should be aware and well-focused on these quality attributes and not only the activities performed with them. Consistent and controlled shipment, storage, handling and preparation conditions and methods are critical for reproducible performance of the media. The application of Shewhart charts to trend the quality attributes of culture media batches provides internal monitoring for important characteristics of these media in a microbiology laboratory. Two approaches can be used, variable or attribute
control charts. Both can be customized according to the nature of laboratory activity in terms of number and frequency of the prepared and tested-culture media. Variable control charts can be used for a limited number of measurable properties of media such as thickness of the solid media, gel strength and pH, while attribute charts are suitable for monitoring of defects for microbiological culture media. Some of the quality
characteristics may have certain specification limit (SL) values such as growth promotion (GP) failure rate, the depth of the agar medium in the culture plate, gel strength, contaminated fraction from total batch and pH. Thus, the statistical process control (SPC) may be useful in the assessment, control, investigation-on-failure and prediction of the performance of microbiological culture media. Shewhart control charts provide the microbiologist with a tool for quality monitoring and improvement of the prepared culture media.
References
Edn. CRC Press, 2010.
2. Basu S, Pal A, Desai PK. Quality control of culture
media in a microbiology laboratory. Indian Journal
of Medical Microbiology Jul 2005; 23(3): 159.
3. Clontz L. Microbial Limit and Bioburden Tests:
Validation Approaches and Global Requirements.
2nd Edn. CRC Press, 2008.
4. Selective and Differential Media for Identifying
Microorganisms (Theory): Microbiology Virtual Lab
I: Biotechnology and Biomedical Engineering.
Amrita Vishwa Vidyapeetham Virtual Lab, 2016.
Available from: http://vlab.amrita.edu/?sub=3
&brch=73&sim=720&cnt=15.
5. Evans GL, Bell RH, Cunningham LV et al. Quality
Assurance for Commercially Prepared
Microbiological Culture Media: Approved
Standards. 2nd Edn. NCCLS M22-A2 1996; 16(23): 3.
6. Ferraro MJ, Wikler MA, Craig WA et al. Performance
Standards for Antimicrobial Disk Susceptibility
Tests: Approved Standards. 8th Edn. NCCLS M2-A8,
2003: 23.7. Bridson EY. Culture media. The Oxoid Manual. 8th
Edn. OXOID England: Limited Hampshire, 1998: 2-8.
8. Sutton S. Quality Control of Microbiological Culture
Media. The Microbiology Network 2016. Available
from: http://www.microbiol.org/resources/mono
graphswhite-papers/quality-control-of-microbiologi
cal-culture-media/.
9. Curtis G. A review of methods for quality control of
culture media. International Journal of Food
Microbiology 1985; 2(1-2): 13-20.
10. United States Pharmacopeia (USP). <71> Sterility
test interim announcement. Pharm Forum Jul/Aug
2003; 29(4): 933-40.
11. United States Pharmacopeia (USP). <1117>
Microbiological best laboratory practices. Pharm
Forum Sept/Oct 2004; 30(5): 1713-21.
12. Sutton S. Quality control of microbiological culture
media. PMF Newsletter Jan 2006; 12(1): 2-11.
13. Krisher K. The quality control of microbiological
media revisited: Is it time for a change? Clinical
Microbiology Newsletter 1999; 21(20): 161-62.
14. Nagel JG, Kunz LJ. Needless retesting of qualityassured,
commercially prepared culture media.
Applied Microbiology Jul 1973; 26(1): 31-37.
15. United States Pharmacopeia (USP). <61>
Microbiological examination of non-sterile
products: Microbial enumeration tests. Pharm
Forum Sept/Oct 2003; 29(5): 1714-22.
16. United States Pharmacopeia (USP). <62>
Microbiological examination of non-sterile
products: tests for specified microorganisms
harmonization. Pharm Forum Sept/Oct 2003; 29(5):
1722-35.
17. CLSI. Quality Control for Commercially Prepared
Microbiological Culture Media: Approved Standard.
3rd Edn. M22-A3 (ISBN 1-56238-536-4). Clinical and
Laboratory Standards Institute (formerly the
National Committee on Clinical Laboratory
Standards (NCCLS)), Wayne, PA, 2004.
18. Cundell AM. Comparison of microbiological testing
practices in clinical, food, water and pharmaceutical
microbiology in relation to the microbiological
attributes of nutritional and dietary supplements.
Pharmacopeial Forum May 2002; 28: 964-85.
19. Weenk G. Microbiological assessment of culture
media: Comparison and statistical evaluation of
methods. International Journal of Food
Microbiology 1992; 17(2): 159-81.
20. Ilstrup DM. Statistical methods in microbiology.
Clinical Microbiology Reviews Jul 1990; 3(3): 219-26.
21. Miles AA, Misra SS, Irwin JO. The estimation of the
bactericidal power of the blood. Journal of Hygiene
Nov 1938; 38(6): 732-49.
22. Mossel DA, Rossem FV, Koopmans M et al. Quality
control of solid culture media: A comparison of the
classic and the so?called ecometric technique.
Journal of Applied Bacteriology Dec 1980; 49(3):
439-54.
23. Aspinall LJ, Kilsby DC. A microbiological quality
control procedure based on tube counts. Journal of
Applied Bacteriology Apr 1979; 46(2): 325-29.
24. Morgan CA, Bigeni P, Herman N et al. Production of
precise microbiology standards using flow
cytometry and freeze drying. Cytometry Part A Dec
2004; 62(2): 162-68.
25. FDA U. Bacteriological analytical manual.
Gaithersburg, MD: AOAC International, 1998; 1:
2011.
26. Growth a. Slideshare.net. 2016. Available from: ht
tp://www.slideshare.net/astralfilledsky/growth-a.
27. Bass I. Six sigma statistics with Excel and Minitab.
New York: McGraw-Hill, 2007.
28. Mini Sigma: How to achieve six sigma benefits on a
tight budget how, why and when to apply basic
analysis tools to boost the bottom line. DataNet
Quality Systems 2016. Available from: http://
www.winspc.com/downloads/Mini-Sigma.pdf.
29. Benneyan JC. Design, use, and performance of
statistical control charts for clinical process
improvement. Northeastern University, Boston MA,
Sep 2001.
30. Brian C, McDaniel M. Statistical Process Control
(SPC) Tutorial. 2016. Available from:
https://www.moresteam.com/toolbox/statisticalprocess-
control-spc.cfm.
31. Minitab, Inc. Minitab reference manual. Minitab,
2016.
32. Documentation-Minitab. 2016. Available from:
https://www.minitab.com/en-us/support/documen
tation/.
33. Gygi C, DeCarlo N, Williams B. Six sigma for
dummies. Hoboken: Wiley Pub, 2005.
34. Woodall WH, Adams BM, Benneyan JC. The use of
control charts in healthcare. Statistical methods in
Healthcare Jul 2012: 251-67.
35. G Control Chart | BPI Consulting. 2016. Available
from: https://www.spcforexcel.com/knowledge/
attribute-control-charts/g-control-chart.
36. Control chart types what’s the difference between
variable and attribute control charts? QI Macros.
2016. Available from: https://www.
qimacros.com/control-chart/control-chart-types/.
37. Benneyan JC, Lloyd RC, Plsek PE. Statistical process
control as a tool for research and healthcare
improvement. Quality and Safety in Health Care Dec
2003; 12(6): 458-64.38. Quality remix: VOC and VOP loops explained. 2010.
Available from: http://www.qualitymag.com/blogs
/14-quality-blog/post/84737-quality-remix-voc-andvop-
loops-explained.
39. Voice of the customer (VOC) gathering and
determination. 2016. Available from: http://
www.six-sigma-material.com/Voice-of-the-Custo
mer.html.
40. Control Limits and Specification Limits-Content
Development-SAP Library. 2016. Available from:
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_mii150sp00/helpdata
/en/53/2d00efed7510e5e10000000a42189c/conte
nt.htm.
41. Statistical Process Analysis using NWA Quality
Analyst software and Agilent OpenLAB ECM
Intelligent Reporter. Application Note of Agilent
Technologies. 2016. Available from: http://
www.agilent.com/cs/library/applications/5991-54
40EN_SPC_with_Quality_Analyst_Usage_AppNote.
pdf.
42. Pyzdek T, Keller P. Six Sigma Hand Book. Chicago,
Ill.: McGraw-Hill Education LLC, 2014.
43. Knowles G. Six Sigma. Bookboon, 2011.